I use Scroogle Scraper to check my rankings. You can put 100 results up at a time so 7 pages of results is pretty easy to scan through. Ranking 736,737 and 738 today.

Muskyblood: there are ranking trackers available that tell you where you are in the search results. Market Samurai is probably my favourite. Craig, let us know how you get on and what fixes it, may help others in the same boat! Best of luck.

Labman, I know many of us are struggling with money, but if you have, at some stage, 77 dollars to spare I highly recommend RPGtutor service here at WA for getting backlinks to your site and helping it get on to page 1.
Go to the forum and check out the thread of people who have used this service, including myself, excellent service for building up your site. My Ukulele site was sitting on page 2 and 3 for a couple of months now and after getting some help it now sits on page 1 in all servers. Check it out in the forum, hope it can help.

I am sending you some gold because of your help this past couple of weeks. I don't want WA to eat it up. lol

How do you know you went to #750? Do you scroll through that many pages until you find your site? I always quit after 30-40 if I can't find a site...