Deciding when good is ‘good enough’

Last Update: May 16, 2012

I struggle with perfectionism.  Not in all areas of my life (thank goodness) but certainly with anything creative.  So anything internet marketing related can be quite painful at times.

My first degree was in fashion and I agonised over my fashion notebooks going backwards and forwards over the pages.   If there was just one drawing  that I didn’t like, I would rip out the whole page and redraw it.  Then I would get upset because I would have a notebook with ripped pages – spoiling the entire look (or so I thought)  and then I would have to start the whole notebook again.  I actually made myself ill over it.  Complete madness.

I would love to say that I was twenty when this happened but I wasn’t – I was 37 and by then it was a well established habit and sadly I’m still doing it – but instead of notebooks I do it with web pages!

This was brought home to me the other day when Kyle suggested in the live chat that some of use might like to try some infographic software. ( Infographics for anyone who doesn’t know i are graphic visual representations of information, data or knowledge.)

I was in there immediately.  Something creative – brilliant – I couldn’t get there fast enough. 
Five minutes later I was away and started to create my first infographic about key factors for successful goal achievement  (ability, attitude and motivation) 

I played around that evening and into the next day.  I completed 5 in total and I agonised over each one, changing colours, text, pictures over and over again. Sometimes having those arty skills can feel a definite curse.

Eventually, I posted four on my blog and I told a handful of people about them – to show I had tried the software.  Every compliment I received  I kept saying things like ‘they’re a little bit naff’, ‘I’m going to take them down soon’ and I meant it.    Secretly I thought they were very mediocre indeed.

But actually despite what I said, they’re still there.  I have improved them all  but they’re still far from being  perfect and I am itching to see if I can make them better still.  However, I suddenly decided not to take them down.

I had to sit on my perfectionism and acknowledge they are engaging, there are some strong messages, they are visually pleasing and they are good and more importantly they really are ‘good enough’.  (even if I’m thinking ‘only for now’)

What bought about the change of heart? Two things. 
1.  Yesterday  I was helping a member of WA who was struggling with an issue and was saying they were useless and what they’d done wasn’t good enough. 

I wasn’t being glib but I reminded them that IM is a learning curve and they will make mistakes and not everything will be ‘perfect’.  You see as a trained coach I'm good at giving advice but not always so good at following it – especially my own.

2.  The second thing that happened was today when I was searching for a quote for a piece of writing I was doing and I came across one  which said  ‘Good is good enough when you’ve done your best’ (and no I don’t know whose quote it is)

A bit corny I know, but I thought – yep that’s the measure I’m going to use for myself in this instance.  I’ve worked hard on these infographics – put a lot of thought into them, they are good and so actually it’s time to stop and move on.

So if you’re like me and you have times when you’re perfectionism actually stands in the way of making progress – pull yourself up.  Doing sloppy work isn’t you – but there does have to come a point when you make that decision – that good is good enough.
Join the Discussion
Write something…
Recent messages
MMetheny Premium
You have touched on one of my personal issues also, thank you for putting a new spin on this issue I have. I get side tracked in my own personal space I forget that another person may have a different perspective. Thanks again
BIS Premium
Thank you for tking the time to read and comment. Glad it struck a chord with you. Although these things affect us differently it's sometimes easy to think that we're the only one with the issue.
Bigman Premium
I'm a perfectionist and it's a nightmare to come to terms with and to accept that whatever I do is good enough. For example I write lots of reviews and sometimes I re-write them several times until they become so full of errors that I don't know what to do.
In some ways I think I have OCD where I am very critical of what I do, instead of thinking, "you did a good job there" and time to move on.
I was brought up with a belief that you always had to give 100% even if at times this wasn't achievable.
When is good? good enough, for me I don't know.
Now I use a friend to proof read for me, otherwise I would be back to square one.
BIS Premium
I think that's the issue. You may never know what is good enough for you and therefore you have to use strategies as you are to, compensate for that and make the feelings of perfectionism manageable. I too was bought up with the same belief as you that you should always give a 100% but even that means different things to each of us.
Praise Premium
The pursuit of perfection is fueled by the perspective of 'the glass is half empty' - 'it's not good enough' while the pursuit of 'best effort' is fueled by the perspective of 'the glass is half full' - 'it is good enough'.

From experience, having an 'it's not good enough' attitude/belief can be paralyzing.

Thanks for sharing.
BIS Premium
Thanks for reading Sharon and taking the time to comment. I'm afraid I have often been the glass is half empty type of person. but I try and stamp on it.
Sielke Premium
Beverly, I totally understand where you're coming from. Early in my career I worked long hours trying to get a design exactly right. I've learned to temper my perfectionism because I realize what matters is results, thats where you need to be perfect, driving results. You can never lose that trait but you can learn how to hone it to work the way you want it to work.
BIS Premium
Thanks Sielke. You are so right - it is the results that matter and I shall contine to remind myself of that.
mhamilt Premium
Good post Beverly. It's something I struggle with also. I spend endless amounts of time trying to get something looking 'just right' - and the more important it is to me, the longer I spend on doing it.

It's also so easy to tell other people what they should and shouldn't do and so difficult to do it yourself. Self-mastery is something that IM has only accelerated me into :-)
BIS Premium
Thanks Mark for taking the time to comment. It's nice to know there are other people who struggle with the same issue

And you are so right about it's easier to give advice than follow it. Somehow thought I always think because I'm a coach I should know better - but it doesn't always work that way!
mhamilt Premium
Yeah, nothing worse then having someone asking for your honest opinion, you telling them, and then walking away cringing because you can't make your suggestion work in your own life! Humans are a funny bunch :-)
Top